Political ideas of conservatism in the context of the development of the historical process in Ukraine 1900–1917
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15407/uhj2017.05.146Keywords:
conservatism, nationalism, ideology.Abstract
The article summarizes the overall essence of the ideology of conservatism, as well as its national models – Russian, Polish and Ukrainian, that formed in Ukrainian regions Russia at the beginning of the 20th century. For each of those models, the fundamental principles and specific features inherent in it were identified. The authors examined their comparative analysis and the possible interrelationships.
References
Bartyzel, J. (2002). Konserwatyzm bez kompromisu. Studium z dziejów zachowawczej myśli politycznej w Polsce w XX wieku. Toruc, 273 p. [in Polish].
Berk, E. (1993). Razmyshlenija o revoljucii vo Francii. Moskva: Rudomino, 90 p. [in Russian].
Bovua, D. (2011). Gordiev uzel Rossijskoi imperii: Vlast', shljahta i narod na Pravoberezhnoi Ukraine (1793–1914). (M. Krisan' Trans.). Moskva: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 1008 p. [in Russian].
"Bulatov, Ju. (n. d.) (2015). Pol'skii jeksperiment dinastii Romanovyh. Mezhdunarodnaja zhizn' – International life 10. 158–178. [in Russian].
Bulakhtin, M. (2006). Krakivs'ki konservatory i proekty reform u Halychyni na pochatku XX st. Naukovi zoshyty istorychnoho fakul'tetu L'vivs'koho universytetu. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats' – Scientific notebooks of department of history of the Lviv university. Collection of scientific works (8). 152–164. [in Ukrainian].
Cherkas'ka, N. (2007). Pol's'ka shlyakhta na Pravoberezhniy Ukrayini pochatku XX st.: natsional'na ideya chy krayova ideolohiya? Ukrayins'kyy arkheohrafichnyy shchorichnyk – Ukrainian archaeological year-book. 12. 186–206. [in Ukrainian].
Chornovol, I. (2000). Pol's'ko-ukrayins'ka uhoda 1890–1894 rr. L'viv: L'vivs'ka akademiya mystetstv, 247 p. [in Ukrainian].
Doroshenko, A.A. (2004). Pravye v Gosudarstvennoi Dume Rossijskoi imperii. Samara: Izd-vo «NTC», 225 p. [in Russian].
Gula, R.V., Gula,V.D. (2016). Agoniya Leviafana. Chast' I. Passionarii i yurodivye. Politicheskii terror i terrorizm v Ukraine (1900–1914 gg.). Kyiv: Geoprint, 342 p. [in Russian].
"Hyrych I. (n. d.). (2012). Rechnyk konservatyzmu, Tyzhden'. 1 chervnya. [in Ukrainian].
Hula, R.V. (2013). Antysemityzm yak skladova chastyna derzhavnoho patriotyzmu monarkhichnoyi ideolohiyi ta yoho proyavy u roky pershoyi rosiys'koyi revolyutsiyi 1905–1907 rr. (na storinkakh monarkhichnoyi presy). Naukovi zapysky Natsional'noho universytetu "Ostroz'ka akademiya": Istorychni nauky – Scientific notes of the National university "Ostrozhsky Academy". Historical sciences. (20). 142–146. [in Ukrainian].
Hula, R.V. (2013). Istorychnyy, heohrafichnyy ta etnichnyy aspekty yevreys'koho pytannya v Rosiys'koyi imperiyi v redaktors'koyi politytsi hazety “Kyevlyanyn” u 1900–1914 rr. Hileya – Gileya. (77). 92–93. [in Ukrainian].
Kmiecik, Z. (1969). “Kraj” za czasów redaktorstwa Erazma Piltza. Warszawa, 354 p. [in Polish].
"Koval'chuk, N. (n.d.) (2000). Rosiys'kyi neoslavizm i ukrayins'ke pytannya v publitsystytsi Oleksandra Pohodina. Problemy slov"yanoznavstva – Slavic studies problems. (51). 100–106. [in Russian].
Kozak, N.A. (2001). Ukrayins'kyy konservatyzm: istoriya i suchasnist' [Ukrainian conservatism: History and modern]. (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). Lviv, 21 p. [in Ukrainian].
"Kozak, N. (n.d.). Ukrayins'kyy konservatyzm u XX stolitti. [in Ukrainian].
"Kotov A. (n.d.). (2017). "Russkoe latinstvo" 1860-h godov kak jelement ideologii bjurokraticheskogo nacionalizm. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie – New literary review. 144. [in Ukrainian].
Lypyns'kyy, V’yacheslav (2015). Povne zibrannya tvoriv, arkhiv, studiyi. (Vol. 1.): Suspil'no-politychni tvory (1908-1917). Kyiv: Ukrayins'kyy pys'mennyk, 784 p. [in Ukrainian].
Lypyns'kyy, V. (1991). Perednye slovo. Tvory, Arkhiv, Studiyi. Tvory. Istorychna sektsiya. Ukrayina na perelomi 1657-1659. Zamitky do istoriyi ukrayins'koho derzhavnoho budivnytstva v XVII-im stolitti. (Vol.3). Kyiv-Filadel'fiya, 356 p. [in Ukrainian].
Men'shikov, M.O. (2004). Nacional'naja imperija. Moskva: Imperskaja tradicija, 512 p. [in Russian].
"Miller, A. (n. d.). Istoricheskaja pamjat' v Pol'she. [in Russian].
"Ohloblyn, O. (n. d.). (1974). Berlins'ka misiya Kapnista 1791 roku. Ukrayins'kyy istoryk – Ukrainian historian. 01-03. [in Ukrainian].
Omel'yanchuk, I.V. (1997). Chornosotenni soyuzy i orhanizatsiyi v Kyevi. Veche. (10). 141–145. [in Russian].
Omel'janchuk, I.V. (2006). Chernosotennoe dvizhenie v Rossijskoi imperii (1901–1914). Kyiv: MAUP, 744 p. [in Russian].
Ostashko, T. (2002). Memorial V’yacheslava Lypyns'koho do Ukrayins'koho informatsiynoho komitetu. Problemy istoriyi Ukrayiny XIX – pochatku XX st. (Vol. 5. pp. 82–92). Kyiv: Instytut istoriyi Ukrayiny NAN Ukrayiny. [in Ukrainian].
Pazyura, N. (n. d.) (2016). Antykvarna prohrama kozats'ko-het'mans'kykh starozhytnostey na storinkakh “Kyevskoy starynu” (do problemy formuvannya staroho ukrayins'koho konservatyzmu). Istoriohrafichni doslidzhennya v Ukrayini – Historiographic researches in Ukraine. (26). 33–48. [in Ukrainian].
Perederii, I. (2014). Relihiynyy chynnyk u protsesi derzhavotvorennya: evolyutsiya viziyi V’yacheslava Lypyns'koho. [Religious factor and process of the state construction: evolution views of V. Lipinsky]. Istoriya relihiy v Ukrayini: naukovyy shchorichnyk – History of religion in Ukraine. Scientific year-book. (Vol.1, pp. 561–570). [in Ukrainian].
"Perederii, I. (n. d.). (2015). Ukrayintsi-latynnyky yak parostok konservatyvnoyi techiyi u zahal'nomu ukrayins'komu natsional'nomu rusi pochatku XX stolittya. [Ukrainians-Latinists as the beginning of a conservative current in the national movement of the beginning of the 20th century]. Istorychna pam’yat' – Historical memory. (33). 33–47. [in Ukrainian].
Perederii, I. (2012). V’yacheslav Lypyns'kyy: etnichnyy polyak, politychnyy ukrayinets'. Poltava: PNTU, 622 p. [in Ukrainian].
"Pol'skij konservatizm – jeto konservatizm, u kotorogo ne bylo gosudarstva. Interv'ju Dariusha Shpopera na sajte konservativnoj politicheskoj mysli "Russkaja ideja" (n. d.). [in Russian].
"Popov, Je. A. (n. d.). (2006). Russkii konservatizm: ideologija i social'no-politicheskaja praktika [Russian conservatism: ideology and socio-political practice]. (Extended abstract of Doctor’s thesis). [in Russian].
Potul'nyts'kii, V. (1999). Shlyakhta i konservatyvna derzhavna ideya v Ukrayini u XIX–XX st.: problemy istoriohrafiyi ta istoriosofiyi. Studiyi z arkhivnoyi spravy ta dokumentoznavstva. (Vol. 5, pp. 33–38.). [in Ukrainian].
Repnikov, A.V. (2001). Metamorfozy russkogo konservatizma: ot S.S. Uvarova do Nikity Mihalkova (Russkij konservatizm: problemy, podhody, mnenija. «Kruglyi stol»). Otechestvennaja istorija – National history. 3. 105–109. [in Russian].
Repnikov, A.V. (2001). Social'naja problematika v rabotah russkih konservatorov nachala XX veka. Prizvanie istorika. Problemy duhovnoi i politicheskoi zhizni Rossii. Sbornik statei. K 60-letiju professora, doktora istoricheskih nauk V.V. Shelohaeva. (pp. 202–220). Moskva: ROSSPEN. [in Russian].
"Repnikov, A.V. (n. d.). (2006). Konservativnye koncepcii pereustrojstva Rossii v kontekste istoricheskogo processa konca XIX – nachala XX vv. [Conservative concepts of reorganization of Russia in the context of historical process of the end XIX – the beginnings of the XX th century]. (Extended abstract of Doctor’s thesis). Moskva. [in Russian].
Repnikov, A.V. (2006). Konservativnye predstavlenija o pereustrojstve Rossii (konec XIX nachalo XX vekov). Moskva: Gotika, 424 p. [in Russian].
"Repnikov, A.V. (n. d.) (2007). Russkii konservatizm: Konstantin Leont'ev. Perspektivy. [in Russian].
Repnikov, A.V., Grebenkin, I.N. (2010). Vasilii Vital'evich Shul'gin. Voprosy istorii – History questions. 5. 25–40. [in Russian].
Repnikov, A.V. (2012). Razmyshlenija o konservatizme. Svobodnaja mysl' – Free thought. 11/12. 103–116. [in Russian].
Rogger, H. (1964). Was There a Russian Fascism? The Union of The Russia People. Journal of Modern History. 36. 398–415. [in English]. doi: https://doi.org/10.1086/239491
San'kova, S.M. (2009). Rossijskaja monarhija v predstavlenii ideologov gosudarstvennogo nacionalizma. Vlast' – Authorities. 2. 102–105. [in Russian].
"Semenyaka, O. (n. d.). Porivnyannya ideolohiyi nimets'koyi konservatyvnoyi revolyutsiyi ta ukrayins'koho konservatyzmu. [in Ukrainian].
Slin'ko, A.A. (2001). Rekonstrukcija budushhego: russkii klassicheskii konservatizm o geopolitike. In A. Minakov (Ed.). Konservatizm v Rossii i v mire: proshloe i nastojashhee (Vol. 1, pp. 21–25). Voronezh : Izd-vo VGU. [in Russian].
"Shljahta, B. (n. d.). (2013). Pol'skaja konservativnaja mysl' v novoe i novejshee vremja. Ars Administrandi – Perm'. (2). 19–25. [in Russian].
Shpoper, D. (2006). Politicheskie iniciativy pol'skoi shljahty v zapadnyh gubernijah Rossijskoi imperii nakanune vosstanija 1863 g. Otechestvennaja istorija– National history. 8. 90–103. [in Russian].
Shul'gin, V.V. (1992). Chto nam v nih ne nravitsja. Moskva: Hors, 287 p. [in Russian].
"Spor o Rossii" v perepiske Vasilija Maklakova i Vasilija Shul'gina (2013). Rossijskaja istorija –Russian history. 2. 3–43. [in Russian].
Tvardovskaja, V.A. (2000). Agrarnyj vopros v konservativnoj mysli Rossii v 80-e gody XIX veka. In V.A. Vinogradov (Ed.). Ekonomicheskaja istorija Rossii XIX–XX v.: sovremennyj vzgljad . 509–523. Moskva. [in Russian].
"Zachem nuzhno pobedit' Rossiju (n. d.). Pustoshhi shidnoevropejs'koi Klio. [in Russian].
"Zashkil'nyak, L. (n. d.). (2010–2011). Do genezy ukrayins'ko-pol's'koho konfliktu u XX stolitti. Ukrayina-Pol'shcha: istorychna spadshchyna i suspil'na svidomist'. (3-4). 22–41. [in Ukrainian].
Zashkil'nyak, L. (1998). L'viv yak tsentr formuvannya ukrayins'koyi nauky (druha polovyna XIX st.). In K. Karolczak (Ed.). Lwiw. Miasto, spoieczecstwo, kultura. (Vol. 2, pp. 387–402). Krakiw [in Ukrainian].
Zhuk, A. (2002). Yak diyshlo do zasnuvanya "Soyuzu vyzvolennya Ukrayiny" (Spomyny u 20-littya Soyuzu). Moloda natsiya: Al'manakh. 3 (24). 35 – 150. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Zhuravlev, V.V. (Ed.). (2016). Patriotizm i nacionalizm kak faktory rossijskoj istorii (konec XVIII – 1991 g.). Kollektivnaja monografija. Moskva: Politicheskaja jenciklopedija, 783 p. [in Russian].
