State Center of Ukrainian People’s Republic in Exile in 1920–1992: Historiography of the Problem
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15407/uhj2020.04.155Keywords:
state tradition, historiography, political organization, Ukrainian diplomacy, Ukrainian political emigration, Ukrainian liberation movement, State Center of Ukrainian People’s Republic in exileAbstract
The purpose of the article is to analyze the historiographical basis of the problem of evaluating the activities of State Center of Ukrainian People’s Republic in exile in 1920–1991
The methodological basis is a critical typological analysis of related works. During the study the author used the comparative, problem-chronological method and the method of the retrospective analysis. This allowed to compare different opinions and assessments about the activities and legitimacy of State Center of Ukrainian People’s Republic in exile.
The scientific novelty is a review of key explorations of domestic and foreign scientists. Apart from academic discourse, attention is also paid to a wide range of relevant works – brochures, memoirs, articles, some of which are little known to the scientific community and the general public.
Conclusion. A number of academic works, memoirs and articles are devoted to the activities of State Center of Ukrainian People’s Republic in exile. The complex description of scientific works devoted to the researched problem gives grounds to say that quite contradictory positions of researchers on political and legal assessment of creation, legal status and activity of State Center of Ukrainian People’s Republic in exile in Ukrainian historiography are caused by their different political and ideological positions. Therefore, today there is no comprehensive academic intelligence that would reflect a holistic picture of the activities of Ukrainian People’s Republic government in exile. The issue of the legal status of the emigrant government of Ukrainian People’s Republic from the point of view of international law also needs further coverage.
References
Bruski, J. (2005). Petlurowcy: Centrum Państwowe Ukraińskiej Republiki Ludowej na wychodźstwie (1919–1924). Krakiv. [in Polish].
Karpus, Z. (2001). Russian and Ukrainian prisoners of war and internees kept in Poland in 1918–1924. Torun.
Livytskyi, A. (2019). Lystuvannia (1919–1953 roku). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Livytskyi, M. (1984). DTs UNR v ekzyli mizh 1920 i 1940 rokamy. Miunkhen, Filadelfiia. [in Ukrainian].
Livytskyi, M. (1965). Perspektyvy ukrainskoi vyzvolnoi polityky. Ukrainska Narodna Respublika – dorohovkaz na majbutnie. Niu-York. [in Ukrainian].
Livytskyi, M. (1960). Vymushena vidpovid. Niu-Ulm. [in Ukrainian].
Maliuta, O. (2007). Orhany vlady ZUNR ta UNR v ekzyli u 20–40-i rr. XX st.: borotba za natsionalnu derzhavnist yak formu orhanizatsii povsiakdennoho zhyttia ukrainskoi emihratsii. Ukraina XX st.: kultura, ideolohiia, polityka, 4, 287–308. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Muzyka, I. (2018). Dokumentalna spadshchyna DTs UNR v ekzyli yak pamiatka pravovoi dumky. Pravova derzhava, 29, 505–514. [in Ukrainian].
Neduzhko, Yu. (2008). Borotba ukrainskoi diaspory za demokratiiu ta derzhavnu nezalezhnist Ukrainy (kinets 70-kh – pochatok 90-kh rr. XX st.). Naukovi zapysky Natsionalnoho universytetu „Ostrozka akademiia”: Istorychni nauky, 11. 90–112. [in Ukrainian].
Neduzhko, Yu. (2009). Ukrainska diaspora v protsesi vidnovlennia derzhavnoi nezalezhnosti Ukrainy (seredyna 40-kh – pochatok 90-kh rr. XX st.). Lutsk. [in Ukrainian].
Pankivskyi, K. (1968). Vid komitetu do Derzhavnoho tsentru. Niu-Jork, Toronto. [in Ukrainian].
Panova, I. (2009). Utvorennia Derzhavnoho tsentru UNR v ekzyli: polityko-pravovyi aspekt. Chasopys Kyivskoho universytetu prava, 3, 78–85. [in Ukrainian].
"Parandii, V. (2015). Diialnist viiskovoi spetssluzhby Derzhavnoho Tsentru UNR v ekzyli (1926–1936 rr.). Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal, 6, 27–31. [in Ukrainian].
Parandii, V. (2017). Peredumovy formuvannia derzhavnoi instytutsii DTs UNR v ekzyli. Porivnialno-analitychne pravo, 3, 44–47. [in Ukrainian].
Pisuliński, J. (2010). Centrum państwowe Ukraińskiej Republiki Ludowej na wychodźstwie w polskiej polityce zagranicznej po 1926 r. Istorychnyi arkhiv, 5, 120–124. [in Polish].
Pisuliński, J. (2013). Nie tylko Petlura: Kwestia ukraińska w polskiej polityce zagranicznej w latach 1918–1923. Torun. [in Polish].
Piskun, V. (2006). Politychnyi vybir ukrainskoi emihratsii (20-ti rr. XX st.). Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
"Sidak, V. Viiskova spetssluzhba Derzhavnoho tsentru UNR v ekzyli ta yii kerivnyky (1926–1938 rr.). [in Ukrainian].
Sribniak, I. (1995). Viiskova diialnist uriadu UNR v ekzyli (1921–1923 rr.). Extended abstract of candidate’s thesis. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Trembitskyi, V. (1986). Pravni pidstavy Ekzylnoho uriadu Ukrainy (1920–1985). Oko svitu, 2, 35. [in Ukrainian].
Troshchynskyi, V. (1994). Mizhvoienna ukrainska emihratsiia v Yevropi yak istorychne i sotsialno-politychne yavyshche. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Vovk, O., Dzeiko, Zh. (2002). Politychno-hromadski orhany Ukrainskoi Narodnoi Respubliky v 1920–1992 rr. (istoryko- pravovyi aspekt). Chasopys Kyivskoho universytetu prava, 4, 65–72. [in Ukrainian].
Viedienieiev, D., Budkov, D. (2006). Yunist ukrainskoi dyplomatii: Stanovlennia zovnishnopolitychnoi sluzhby Ukrainskoi derzhavy: 1917–1923 rr. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Wiszka, E. (2004). Emigracja ukraińska w Polsce 1920–1939. Torun. [in Polish].
Yablonskyi, V. (2014). Derzhavnyi tsentr UNR v roky Druhoi svitovoi viiny. Naukovi pratsi Kamianets-Podilskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. Ivana Ohiienka: Istorychni nauky, 24, 327–337. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2010). Isak Mazepa v „ohni i buri revoliutsii” ta emihratsii. Visnyk Kamianets-Podilskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. Ivana Ohiienka: Istorychni nauky, 3, 353–362. Kamianets-Podilskyi. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2013). Istorychni peredumovy vynyknennia ta diialnosti ekzylnoho uriadu UNR. Naukovi pratsi Kamianets- Podilskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. Ivana Ohiienka: Istorychni nauky, 23, 380–387. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2015). Konsolidatsiia ukrainskykh emihratsiinykh politychnykh syl i hetmanskyi rukh (seredyna 1940 – pochatok 1950 rr.). Naukovi pratsi Kamianets-Podilskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. Ivana Ohiienka: Istorychni nauky, 25, 362–370. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2014). „Konstytutsiia” Derzhavnoho tsentru UNR v ekzyli u 1948–1992 rr. Problemy vyvchennia istorii Ukrainskoi revoliutsii 1917–1921 rr., 10, 330–348. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2011). Lyst D.Skoropadskoho do Dm.Andriievskoho. Visnyk Kyivskoho natsionalnoho linhvistychnoho universytetu: Seriia “Istoriia, ekonomika, filosofiia”, 16, 81–86. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2014). Lysty z providnykh kruhiv UNR. Istorychnyi zbirnyk Melitopolskoho derzhavnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu im. Bohdana Khmelnytskoho, 2, 152–161. Melitopol. [in Ukrainian].
"Yablonskyi, V. (2017). Osoblyvosti spryiniattia UNR v Ukraini pislia proholoshennia nezalezhnosti. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2013). Totalitaryzm chy demokratiia: borotba idei v ukrainskomu emihratsiinomu seredovyshchi (20– 30 rr. XX st.). Ukrainoznavchyi almanakh, 13, 185–191. Kyiv; Melitopol. [in Ukrainian].
Yablonskyi, V. (2013). Ukrainska politychna emihratsiia UNR i tradytsii parlamentaryzmu u XX st. Visnyk Kamianets- Podilskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. Ivana Ohiienka: Istorychni nauky, 6, 600–610. [in Ukrainian].
Yanevskyi, D. (2003). Politychni systemy Ukrainy 1917–1920 rokiv: sproby tvorennia i prychyny porazky. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].
