Laughing at VChK—OGPU—NKVD: The Soviet State Security Agencies in the Anecdotes (1920s—1930s)

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15407/uhj2023.05.151

Keywords:

political anecdotes, repressions, terror, VChK—OGPU—NKVD

Abstract

The article aims to characterize the political anecdotes about the Soviet state security agencies, which went viral and their role in the Soviet socio-cultural environment in the 1920s and 1930s during intensifying repressions and terror mainly.

This research is based on three classical theories of humor: the incongruity theory (jokes have a double meaning or there are social roles displacement), the superiority theory (the response of weak people to their suppressors), and the relief theory (decreasing social tension).

The scientific novelty lies in the identification, systematization, and interpretation of Soviet political anecdotes of the 1920s and 1930s dedicated to VChK—OGPU—NKVD.

Conclusions. In the article, the Soviet anecdotes are ranked as a part of the culture of popular laughter. There are no specific Ukrainian features in the identified anecdotes as these were themes, genres, etc., adapted for the Ukrainian consumer. The political humor of the ordinary people was the reflection of the socio-political events that took place in the Soviet Union in the 1920s and 1930s. In the USSR, political anecdotes were the focus of close attention by the authorities, as they were qualified as a manifestation of counter-revolutionary activity and could lead to persecution according to the Criminal Code. On the one hand, the internal intelligence agencies of the USSR recorded political anecdotes and, on the other hand, the VChK—OGPU—NKVD became the subject of irony and jokes. While in the 1920s, anecdotes focused on the struggle of OGPU against speculation, NEPmen, and cooperators, in the 1930s, the themes changed. The activities of the NKVD, which were associated with night searches and arrests, torture during interrogation, political repression, and trials against “enemies of the people”, gave rise to the political jokes in the period known as the Great Terror. The humor of ordinary people performed several functions in the time of terror. Laughter helped to overcome the fear of power and aggression. Political anecdotes about the Chekists were an example of routine resistance. Besides, that kind of humor also was supposed to entertain people. The political anecdotes were the specific marker of the political moods of the population in the Soviet Union, but they cannot be considered as a form of political struggle.

References

Davies, C. (2014). Political ridicule and humour under socialism. European Journal of Humour Research. 2 (3): 1-27. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.7592/EJHR2014.2.3.davies

Akrhipova, A. (2001). Anekdot v zarubezhnykh issledovaniyakh. Zhivaya starina. 1: 30-32. [in Russian].

Thurston, R. (1991). Social Dimensions of Stalinist Rule: Humor and Terror in the USSR, 1935—1941. Journal of Social History. (24) 3: 543-562. doi: https://doi.org/10.1353/jsh/24.3.541

Davies, C. (2007). Humour and Protest: Jokes under Communism. International Review of Social History. 52 (S15): 291-305. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020859007003252

Fitspatrik, Sh. (2008). Povsednevnyj stalinizm. Sotsialnaya istoriya Sovetskoj Rossii v 1930-e gody: gorod. Moscow. [in Russian].

Lauchlan, I. Laughter in the Dark: Humour under Stalin. In: Duncan A. (ed.). Le rire europeen. Perpignan, 2009.

Chornopyskyi, M. (2001). Folklorna politychna satyra 20-kh rr. XX st. u zapysakh Serhiia Yefremova. Lviv. [in Ukrainian].

Holovetska, N. (2007). Ukrainskyi politychnyi anekdot na storinkakh “Shchodennykiv. 1923—1929” Serhiia Yefremova. Narodna tvorchist ta etnolohiia. 5: 3-26. [in Ukrainian].

Stiazhkina, O. (2001). Smikhova kultura Ukrainy druhoi polovyny XX st.: osvoiennia zhinochoho obrazu. Etnichna istoriia narodiv Yevropy. 10: 21-29. [in Ukrainian].

Deliia, O. (2013). Humorystychnyi folklor yak fenomen ukrainskoi radianskoi povsiakdennosti 20—30-kh rr. Hileia: naukovyi visnyk. 72: 115-118. [in Ukrainian].

Kahanov, Yu. (2012). “Smikh kriz slozy”: Radianska Ukraina v dzerkali politychnoho anekdotu. Naukovi pratsi istorychnoho fakultetu Zaporizkoho natsionalnoho universytetu. XXXIV: 106-109. [in Ukrainian].

Yeremieieva, K. (2015). Radianska vlada ta rosiiany v radianskykh politychnykh anekdotakh na ukrainsku tematyku. Aktualni problemy vitchyznianoi ta vsesvitnoi istorii. 14: 82-93. [in Ukrainian].

Yeremieieva, K., Kulikov, V. (2011). Radianskyi politychnyi anekdot yak forma povsiakdennoho sprotyvu. Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. V.N. Karazina. Ser.: Istoriia. (982) 44: 228-239. [in Ukrainian].

Kyrchiv, R. (2008). Etiudy do studii nad ukrainskym narodnym anekdotom. Lviv. [in Ukrainian].

"Yeremieieva, K. (2016). Politychnyi humor Radianskoi Ukrainy u 1941—1991 rr. (na prykladi zhurnalu “Perets”). Kharkiv. [in Ukrainian].

Stiazhkina, O. (2020). Soviet Russian: translation losses as a weapon of information warfare against Ukraine (2013—2020). Ukraina XX st.: kultura, ideolohiia, polityka. 25: 5-42.

Masenko, L. (2017). Mova radianskoho totalitaryzmu. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].

"Zabuzhko, O. (1990). Mova i vlada. Dnipro. 11. [in Ukrainian].

"Shylo, O. (Comps.) Sovetski anekdoty. [in Ukrainian].

Senko, H. (1956). Pidsovietski anekdoty. Buenos-Aires. [in Ukrainian].

Semenko, Yu. (Comps.). (1964). Narodnie slovo. Zbirnyk suchasnoho ukrainskoho folkloru. Munchen. [in Ukrainian].

Chemerys, V. L. (Comps.). (1995). Ukrainski anekdoty. Vid kozatskykh chasiv do nashykh dniv. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].

"Yuryk, P. (Comps.). (2003). Tilky Stalin na stini. Folklor epokhy sotsializmu ta budivnytstva komunizmu. Zaporizhzhia. [in Ukrainian].

Melnichenko, M. (2014). Sovetskij anekdot (ukazatel syuzhetov). Moscow. [in Russian].

"Sandler, A. S., Etlis, M. M. (1991). Sovremenniki GULAGa: Kniga vospominanij i razmyshlenij. Magadan. [in Russian].

Solonevich, B. (1937). Molodezh i GPU (ZHizn i borba sovetskoj molodezhi). Sofia. [in Russian].

Yefremov, S. (1997). Shchodennyky, 1923—1929. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].

Graham, S. (2003). A cultural analysis of the russo-soviet anekdot (Ph. D. dissertation). University of Pittsburgh.

Kuipers, G. (2008). The sociology of humor. In: Raskin V., Ruch W. (ed.). The primer of humor research. Berlin; New York. doi: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110198492.361

Zlobin, N. (1996). Humour as a political protest. Demokratizatsiya. 4: 223-231.

Dmitriev, A. (1996). Sotsiologiya yumora: Ocherki. Moscow. [in Russian].

Peters, Ya. H. (1924). Vospominaniya o rabote v VCHK v pervyj god revolyutsii. Proletarskaya revolyutsiya. Istoricheskij zhurnal. Moscow. 10 (33): 5-32. [in Russian].

Arkhipova, A. (2008). VKHOD i KOT kak anekdot: yazykovye igry v folklore 20-kh gg. XX v. In: Westeijn W. (Ed.). The case of the Avangarde. Amsterdam. 413-447. [in Russian].

Agabekov, G. S. (1996). Sekretnyj terror: Zapiski razvedchika. Moscow. [in Russian].

Belozerskaya-Bulgakova, L. E. (1990). Vospominaniya. Moscow. [in Russian].

Norman, B. Yu. (2006). Igra na granyakh yazyka. Moscow. [in Russian].

Melgunov, S. P. (1995). Krasnyj terror v Rossii. Moscow. [in Russian].

Kostomarov, V. (1999). Yazykovoj vkus epokhi. Moscow. [in Russian].

Kupina, N. (1995). Totalitarnyj yazyk: slovar i rechevye reaktsii. Ekaterinburg; Perm. [in Russian].

Shapoval, Yu., Zolotarov, V. (2010). Yevrei v kerivnytstvi orhaniv DPU—NKVS USRR—URSR u 1920—1930-kh rr. Z arkhiviv VUChK—HPU—NKVD—KHB. 1: 53-93. [in Ukrainian].

Tumshis, M., Zolotaryov, V. (2017). Evrei v NKVD SSSR. 1936—1938 gg. Opyt biograficheskogo slovarya. Moscow. [in Russian].

Pertsov, V. (1927). Anekdot. (Opyt sotsiologicheskogo analiza). Novyj LEF. 3: 41-43. [in Russian].

Bakhtin, M. (1990). Tvorchestvo Fransua Rable i narodnaya kultura srednevekovya i Renessansa. Moscow. [in Russian].

Ungor U., Verkerke V. (2015). Funny as hell: The functions of humour during and after genocide. European Journal of Humour Research. 3 (2/3): 80-101. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.7592/EJHR2015.3.2.3.ungor

Berhson, A. (1994). Smikh. Narysy pro znachennia komichnoho. Kyiv. [in Ukrainian].

Yakovlev, A. N. (Ed.), Khaustov, V. N., Naumov, V. P. Plotnikova, N. S. (Comps.). (2004). Lubyanka. Stalin i Glavnoe upravlenie gosbezopasnosti NKVD. Arkhiv Stalina. Dokumenty vysshikh organov partijnoj i gosudarstvennoj vlasti. 1937—1938. Moscow. [in Russian].

Shinkarchuk, S. (1998). Politicheskij anekdot 1920—1930-kh gg. i obshchestvennoe mnenie naseleniya Sovetskoj Rossii. Klio. 2: 92-96. [in Russian].

Published

2023-10-31

How to Cite

Kuzina, K. (2023). Laughing at VChK—OGPU—NKVD: The Soviet State Security Agencies in the Anecdotes (1920s—1930s). Ukrainian Historical Journal, (5), 151–166. https://doi.org/10.15407/uhj2023.05.151

Issue

Section

HISTORICAL ARTICLES